Christmas Treat Ideas

Over on our Instagram page, we asked everyone to send in their best Christmas treat ideas, and boy did we get some delicious responses! We had requests to share the list once we had it all put together, so here ya go. This list has a little bit of everything from places to buy the best treats and what you need to order there. We are sure you are going to get some inspiration of what to make sure you have on hand this holiday season.

Sweet Tooth Fairy: Holiday Sugar Cookie

The Sweet Tooth Fairy has 5 locations from St. George to Layton, and offers nationwide shipping as well! The perfect addition for any holiday!

Chip: Peppermint Joe Joes

Chip has delivery options for fresh cookies all around Utah, but they also offer shipping! Every month they have a special cookie of the month and these were a big hit in December 2019. Fingers crossed they bring them back this year!

Leatherby’s: Peppermint Ice Cream

Leatherby’s is very well known for their creamy delicious ice cream, so it only stands to reason that their peppermint ice cream would be a foolproof flavor to get for the holidays! They are located in Taylorsville, Orem, and Draper!

JulieAnn Caramels

JulieAnn Caramels is located in Sandy, but can be shipped anywhere! Their caramel is rumored to be delicious and they offer gifts and tins that would make for the perfect gift.

June Pie: Peppermint Chocolate Pie

June Pie is located in Heber, Utah. New pies are posted weekly for you to order and pick up.

The Salty Cookie: Peppermint Cookies

The Salty Cookie Co is located in Saratoga Springs, but delivers through the Little Bread Boy.

Magleby’s: Mint Brownies

Located in Springville and St. George, Magelby’s is an awesome resource for delicious desserts, or even to cater your whole meal.

Banbury Cross: Christmas Donuts

Located in Salt Lake City, Banbury Cross Donuts has tons of delicious treats to choose from.


Kneaders has locations across Utah, from St. George to Logan, and offers one of the biggest varieties of desserts and gift baskets. They are a must for any holiday planning.

Ruby Snap: Virginia

Ruby Snap’s store front is located in Salt Lake City, but also ships and can be found in the freezer section of all Smith’s, Lees, and Harmon’s across Utah.

Swig: Candy Cane Cookie

Swig is well known for their refreshing drinks and tasty cookies. With locations all over Utah, be sure to stop in for a holiday cookie!

Cutler’s Cookies: Gingerdoodle

Cutler’s Cookies has three locations to pick up cookies from: Bountiful, Centerville, and Layton.

Garden Gate: Toffee

Getting your hands on Garden Gate Toffee is like winning the lotto. They are only open for two months out of the year, so if you get some, you will feel like the luckiest person alive. They begin making the toffee in October and then open in November. Once the toffee is gone, it is gone. They close up again in December and then you have to wait till the next year. They are located in Salt Lake City.

Great Harvest: Sugar Cookie

Great Harvest is well known for their breads, but their desserts are top notch too!

Schmidt’s: Eggnog, Peppermint, Wassail, & Orange Desserts

Schmidt’s is a delicious deli and bakery that offers everything from a simple dessert to a fully catered wedding menu.

Hatch Family Chocolates: Everything 🙂

We have been told that you can’t go wrong with buying anything that Hatch Family Chocolates has in their store. It is all delicious and can be used for the perfect Christmas Treats this holiday season.

Crumbl: Peppermint Oreo Cookie

Crumbl does different flavors every week, but maybe if we ask really nicely, they will bring back the peppermint oreo cookie for the holidays!!

Condie’s Candies: English Toffee

English Toffee is definitely a must have for the holidays, and Condie’s knows how to do it right! Stop in to grab this and check out their other Christmas Treat Ideas!

Cravings Alisha’s Cupcakes: Christmas Cupcake

We are no strangers to Cravings Alisha’s Cupcakes. Their cupcakes have been in several of our taste off kits, and was even a winner! You cannot go wrong with any of their tasty desserts!

Did your favorite Christmas Treats make the list? If not, we would love to hear about them and get them added. Comment below with your recommendations of what to try and where. There can never be too many options!

Ultimate Christmas Treat Box Image: Cloudy Kitchen

By |2020-11-09T07:00:35+00:00November 9, 2020|Christmas, Utah Taste Off Recommends|0 Comments
Go to Top